H-1B RFEs: Employer Evidence, Third-Party Worksites, and Current USCIS Rules

Office team members working at computers while wearing headsets

An H-1B request for evidence should be answered under the rules that govern the petition, not an obsolete checklist. The original article centered on the 2010 employer-employee relationship memorandum and its right-to-control factors. USCIS rescinded that memorandum in June 2020, and the modernization rule effective January 17, 2025 further changed the regulatory framework.

The practical objective remains clear: establish a qualifying employer, a real specialty-occupation position, the beneficiary's qualifications, and any requested status or extension eligibility. Contracts, payroll records, organizational charts, and assignment evidence can remain useful, but their relevance depends on the issue USCIS actually raised.

Start with the current legal framework

The June 17, 2020 rescission memorandum withdrew the 2010 employer-employee memorandum and the 2018 contracts-and-itineraries memorandum. Do not present their entire control-factor checklist as current binding law.

The 2025 modernization rule addresses a bona fide job offer, the petitioner's U.S. legal presence and amenability to service of process, a U.S. tax identification number, and other employer requirements. It also addresses beneficiary ownership and third-party placements. The former common-law right-to-control formulation is not the universal current test described in the original article.

This does not eliminate the burden of proof. The petitioner must still provide reliable evidence that the proposed employment actually qualifies. A shell offer, speculative duties, inconsistent client records, or a position that does not require a directly related specialized degree can create substantive problems.

Read the RFE issue by issue

Identify the precise questions, evidence already submitted, requested response date, and any inconsistencies cited by the officer. Common subjects include specialty occupation, educational equivalency, licensing, the actual job offer, LCA correspondence, maintenance of status, and the requested employment period.

An RFE is not a filing rejection or a final denial. A rejection concerns acceptance of the filing; a denial is a merits decision. USCIS does not have to issue an RFE in every legally deficient case, so do not assume there will always be an opportunity to repair a weak initial petition.

Prepare a complete response with an explanatory cover letter and indexed exhibits. Address each material issue directly. A large collection of unrelated documents can obscure the answer, and a partial response may leave an independent denial ground unresolved.

Four employment settings and useful evidence

Work at the petitioner's own office

For an employee working at company headquarters, describe the product or service, actual duties, reporting structure, location, and specialized education requirements. An offer letter, detailed position description, relevant organizational chart, and project information may help establish the real job.

Payroll and benefits records can corroborate ongoing employment, but providing benefits is not a substitute for proving the specialty occupation. If the petition is for future employment, explain that timing rather than suggesting the worker must already have performed unauthorized work to establish eligibility.

An accountant visiting a client's premises

A client-site visit does not automatically defeat H-1B eligibility. Explain the accounting assignment, the employer's role, the worksite, and the specialized duties. Relevant engagement documents can show what services the employer actually agreed to deliver and how the beneficiary's work fits those services.

Distinguish a genuine professional assignment from a generic statement that any client might later need the worker. Check whether the LCA and petition cover the intended locations and employment conditions.

An architect at a construction site

An architect may perform legitimate specialized duties away from the petitioner's office. Project descriptions, relevant contracts, professional licensing, site information, and reporting records can explain the assignment. The physical location alone does not establish who employs the worker or whether the occupation qualifies.

Review licensing and worksite compliance independently. An accurate architectural job description cannot cure a missing required state authorization or an uncovered geographic move.

A software professional assigned to an end client

Third-party placement is not categorically prohibited. Document the actual work, location, specialty requirements, and available assignment. When the worker is staffed to a third party, the third party's actual requirements for the position are important under the current framework.

Client letters, statements of work, contracts, or equivalent reliable evidence may establish the bona fide position. Do not manufacture a letter or copy a degree requirement that the client does not actually impose. If a document is unavailable, explain the circumstances and evaluate other evidence that addresses the same question.

Contracts and itineraries: avoid both extremes

The old blanket itinerary requirement was removed by the modernization rule. That does not mean USCIS can never request a contract or evidence of a real assignment. Relevant contracts or similar documents can be requested to establish that a bona fide position exists for the requested employment.

Nor should an employer assume every short contract automatically limits the petition to that contract's last day without considering the complete evidence and applicable rule. Explain ongoing work, renewal arrangements, projects, and the requested period accurately. Avoid speculative promises of unidentified future employment.

Beneficiary-owners and small companies

An owner is not automatically disqualified from H-1B classification. The current rule expressly accommodates qualifying beneficiary-owners, including controlling owners, subject to additional conditions. The covered owner must spend the majority of time performing specialty-occupation duties, and the initial approval and first extension are generally limited to 18 months.

A separate board with authority to fire the owner is not a universal requirement under today's rules. Nevertheless, the petitioner must be a qualifying employer with a bona fide specialty job. An LLC or corporation's existence alone does not establish eligibility, and describing an arrangement as self-employment does not resolve the legal analysis.

For a startup, business plans, financing, customer arrangements, leases, and operational records may be relevant to the real position. Use them to explain the facts, not as a formula promising approval. Our master's-cap guide also explains why a degree does not create an independent self-petition right.

Extension evidence and prior approvals

For an extension, retain pay statements, W-2 records, employment history, and evidence that the worker performed the authorized job. Timesheets, performance reviews, work product, or client records can be useful where the RFE makes them relevant. Educational records and licenses may address a separate qualifications issue.

Current rules generally provide deference to prior determinations involving the same parties and underlying facts, subject to exceptions such as material error, changed circumstances, or new adverse information. Deference is not an exemption from submitting the required extension evidence. Explain any changed duties, locations, hours, or employer circumstances.

The promotion and amendment guide addresses material changes. A pending extension, a change-of-employer petition, and an expired visa stamp raise different work and status questions; do not treat them interchangeably.

Deadlines, decisions, and next steps

Use the deadline on the actual notice and follow its delivery instructions. Preserve the complete response and proof of delivery. If premium processing applies, an RFE affects the service clock; premium does not reduce the evidence standard or guarantee a favorable result. See our premium-processing guide.

If USCIS denies the petition, review every ground and any appeal or motion rights promptly. The petitioner's procedural options and the worker's immediate employment or departure obligations are separate. Our transfer-denial guide explains why continued work cannot be assumed merely because a challenge is planned.

A practical response file

  • The complete RFE, original petition, receipt, and prior approvals.
  • A point-by-point issue outline identifying the evidence needed for each question.
  • Accurate job, degree, wage, worksite, and assignment records.
  • Relevant employer, client, ownership, and licensing documents.
  • Status and payroll evidence where extension or maintenance is at issue.
  • A final consistency check across forms, letters, dates, and exhibits.

Our filing checklist supports initial preparation. Request a Free Evaluation for a focused review of the notice, current legal standard, missing evidence, and response strategy.

Table of Contents

About Us

Greencardlink.com (also known as Aria Immigration Law Group) is committed to representing clients worldwide who are seeking I-140 immigration petitions.

Our firm has a proven successful track record with employment-based immigration cases, concentrating on EB-1B (Outstanding Professor/Researcher), EB-1A (Extraordinary Ability Alien), EB2-NIW (National Interest Waiver), and EB-1C (Multinational Executive/Manager).

Follow Us

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Get your first consultation

Let our experience be your guide